Oral observations are in and written orders almost out. This unfortunately is not a trend that we could feel happy about. Sometimes a strong observation does the trick but on several occasions it only ends up ruining the case in toto.
Mandamus226 had recently posted an article discussing the manner in which some of the judges spoke in open court. However let us be specific and talk about Justice Ram Mohan Reddy who has this habit of shooting his hat every time he hears a case.
Here are some observations. You decide for yourself whether such comments are necessary or not. Let me tell you something. The best judges are the one’s who spoke less and wrote more. For example Mr. Justice M N Venkatachalaiah.
NGEF liquidation proceedings before Justice Ram Mohan Reddy: The site on which NGEF is situated was put on auction. Counsel for the highest bidder stood up to argue his case. Justice Reddy remarked- “you are nothing but a land shark. Sit down.”
NGEF liquidation proceedings before Justice Ram Mohan Reddy: State Bank of Mysore which is due close to Rs 80 crore from the government is also a party in this litigation. The argument by SBM is that if the land is auctioned, then Rs 80 crore should be returned by the government from the money it gets from the auction. When the counsel for SMB stood up to make his submission, Justice Reddy shot back, “you are an ordinary money lender. Sit down.”
Matter relating to election to local bodies: Justice Reddy sought to know why the reservation list was not drawn out. The government advocate tried justifying the delay. Justice Reddy then shouted back, “it is a Tughlak durbar over there in your government.”
Diamond district matter: Justice Reddy sought to know why some of the officials had not been punished. As usual the government advocate tried explaining. To this Justice Reddy remarked, “ the officers are bandicoots.”
Think about it.
Some arrogance. He sure needs to be controlled. It seems as though matters are only getting worse at his court
Bandicoot. Not a word to be used on the Bench. He thinks he is too smart
Entertaining piece. I pity the lawyer on the receiving end
bandicoot. What is wrong with this judge
SBM a money lender. Either the judge does not know what SBM is or does not know what a money lender is. Either ways he does not know
Land shark. I like that word
In the earlier piece on oral observations there was a discussion regarding video cams in courts. Guess it is high time the system is introduced
Hey tinku i agree with u dude
Video cams, ha, bet the judges don’t have the guts to install one
Can’t anyone complain
whom do you complain to
complain ok but who will listen. what is the use, do u realise how powerful these judges are
The party could complain to the chief justice
Who CJ. Cyriac? I was thinking of complaining against him. Reddy is better than CJ. Reddy reeks of arrogance while the CJ reeks of filth when he talks
I completely agree with the good boy bad boy.
I know who can control Justice Reddy. HIS WIFE
Yes the wife is the best person to control him
Well I feel some advocate should shout back at him. What can he do then
Yes the lawyers should be tough
Shout back. Ha. At the risk of losing the case is it
thats so true. no advocate has the guts to shout back
Just ignore what Reddy says and go on with the case
Ok now Reddy is on the chopping board in this blog. What is the author trying to do? Why can’t u publish the nicer things in the judiciary. I am sure that there are better things happening
Wonderful piece. Well compiled and says a lot about the arrogance in the judiciary
nice write up. I feel that judges should control their tongues
go reddy go. i mean go home
I support u desai. lets get together and send him home
It is time I guess to put an end to judicial terrorism. Enough and more has been spoken. Guess it is time for the Bar to stand united and act
Reddy saab control karo yaar
i fully support Justice Reddy. How else do u get the work done. some amount of fear has to be there in the minds of these officials
I support Karat’s views on this. Some amount of fear is necessary. Has anyone heard the manner in which the officials talk in their offices. well if have not then listen, Justice Reddy is like an angel compared to them
I agree. Judicial terrorism is needed
Justice Reddy has guts. Kudos
Well..his comments are interesting, about the clients !! I pity the advocates though.
well, its time to install CCTVs in court halls too…but, problem is..who will bell the cat.
Oversmart judge
The Judge knows best.
An approach has to be tailored to the occasion.
No pain no gain.
If this is what it takes to get the best outcome then, we have to work with our Judges.
Ram Mohan Rddy is young and inexperienced. Forgive him his ego and know all attitude. He will improve. But why is he fingering small people like the workmen who are starving for 10 years? Why should the banks suffer? Dont they have any rights? Will someone advise him quickly? someone should. And why a special affection for Uday and his Hollagiri? Uday only wants to swallow the land and give it to his political masters. that is obvious. Jai Karnataka!