Don’t forget the cause

By Devil’s Advocate

There is common joke in the courts that most advocates win cases on the basis of face law than case laws. At times it could work in favour of the advocate but on many occasions it could against him also.

We have seen another trend in the courts dealing with public interest litigations. Many a time the courts have rejected PILs while questioning the credibility of the petitioner himself. While I am not trying to suggest that there are no motivated PILs, I would also like to make clear that although some PILs are motivated or filed for personal gains, courts ought to bear in mind that the cause is above anything.

It is heartening to learn that the Supreme Court of India has taken note of this aspect and stated in clear terms that in PIL’s the cause is more important that the credibility of the litigant.

Here are some observations by the Supreme Court which dealt with a similar issue.

 

“In public interest litigation (PIL), even if the bonafides of the litigants are suspect, the courts may still examine the issue on hand after considering the seriousness of the public cause by appointing an amicus curiae.”

“In an exceptional case, where the bonafides of the petitioners are questionable, courts may take the assistance of an amicus curiae, but under no circumstances can the assistance of the doubtful petitioner be sought.”

 

“For the last few years, the inflow of PIL’s has increased manifold. Considerable judicial time is spent in dealing with such cases. A person acting bonafide alone can approach the court in public interest. Such a remedy is not open to an unscrupulous person who acts, in fact, for someone else. The liberal rule of locus standi exercised in favour of a bona fide PIL has immensely helped the cause of justice. Such litigants have drawn the attention of the court.”

 

“Courts should not allow its process to be abused by a mere busybody, a meddlesome interloper, wayfarer or officious intervener without any concern, except for private gain or private profit. PIL is a weapon to be used with great care. The judiciary has to be careful to see that behind the veil of public interest, an ugly private malice is not lurking. Public Interest should not be used for suspicious products of mischief. The process of law should not be abused for oblique considerations by masked phantoms.”

 

Advertisements

10 Responses to Don’t forget the cause

  1. Dipak says:

    A big salute to the supreme court. Judges find it easier to dismiss cases blaming the bonafides of the petitioner. With this ruling, courts cannot forget the cause

  2. Karat says:

    Good order. But how many will practise

  3. hilal says:

    Can this really work. What happens to the petitioner who has filed the PIL with an ulterior motive. Does he get away scot free

  4. biju says:

    Stupid judgment makes no sense. gives a free hand for cheats to file PILs

  5. sainath says:

    Confusing verdict. Dnt know what the supreme court is trying to say

  6. gagan says:

    Good verdict. the cause should never be lost

  7. catalyst says:

    I did not understand anything

  8. Karat says:

    nobody forced u to read

  9. danny says:

    I feel that this judgment is a blessing. Cause is above everything

  10. Vrksha says:

    yes, good observations by supreme court. cause is above all the things. i too agree but, their shd b something to avoid the PILs tht r really Personal Interested Litigation/ Paisa Interested Litigations.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: